What if it's not reality that's the problem, but the way we understand it?
What if it's not reality that's the problem, but the way we understand it?

What if it's not reality that's the problem, but the way we understand it?

It has been said that everything is about perception. It may sound simple, but holds something deeply human. Imagine a leader who repeatedly says something is “fake news.” For many of his followers, this becomes not just an opinion, but a truth. Not necessarily because facts are unambiguous, but because trust, language and belonging shape how reality is perceived. We don't react to reality directly. We respond to our understanding of it. In an era marked by pace, complexity and many perspectives, therefore, one skill is becoming increasingly important for managers, the ability to understand. Not just facts and figures, but people, situations and what happens between us. Here Hans-Georg Gadamer gives us a powerful perspective. His philosophy of hermeneutics is about how we interpret the world, and perhaps more importantly, why we never make it completely neutral.

Why understanding is never neutral

Hermeneutics can be easily explained as the doctrine of interpretation. At Gadamer it goes deeper than method and technique, he points to something fundamentally human. We always interpret. We do not face the world as blank sheets, but with experiences, values and languages that already shape what we see. For a leader, this means something crucial. When you listen to an employee, a customer, or a team, you're not just listening to them, you're also listening through yourself. It makes understanding both powerful and vulnerable.

Five insights that change how you lead

Gadamer's thinking can be translated into practice in a simple and concrete way.

Preconception

You never start from zero. What you have experienced, what you believe in and what you have experienced affects what you notice. Good management is therefore less about being objective and more about being deliberate.

The Hermeneutic Circle

We understand the whole through the parts, and the parts through the whole. Understanding is developed over time, through dialogue and reflection, not through quick conclusions.

Horizon fusion

When your perspective meets someone else's, something new can arise. Real insight doesn't happen when you get it right, but when your understanding expands.

Language shapes reality

The words we use affect what we see and what spaces of action we perceive. A leader who changes language can change how a team understands both problems and opportunities.

Understanding is Dialogue

Understanding is not a technique you apply, but something that happens between people in open and genuine conversations. The question is not just what you get to say, but what you see together.

What does this mean in practice for managers?

This perspective hits right at the core of what many organizations are working on today, psychological security, collaboration and the ability to learn together. In an environment where people dare to challenge, share mistakes and explore uncertainty, this becomes very practical. A leader inspired by Gadamer does nothing more than ask good questions. He or she is genuinely concerned with being influenced, of allowing one's own understanding to change in the face of others.

Here are some concrete moves:

1. Practice discovering your own preconception. Stop in important conversations and ask yourself what you are taking for granted right now. Notice what stories you tell yourself about people, situations and problems.

2. Ask open-ended questions, and wait for the answer. Ask not to confirm what you already believe, but to be challenged and surprised. Give others time to finish thinking before filling the silence.

3. Build dialogue, not discussion. Discussion is often about winning. Dialogue is about understanding, and about allowing the other to have real influence on how you see the matter.

4. Consciously work with language in the team. How do you guys talk about mistakes, risk and learning. Do you use words that invite exploration, or words that shut down. The way you talk affects what actually happens.

5. Allow room for slow comprehension. Not all good answers come quickly. Someone has to mature through several rounds of dialogue, reflection and trial and error. Leadership is also about keeping the space open long enough for new understanding to arise.

Reflection Questions for Managers

  • When was the last time I experienced my own understanding being challenged and actually changed?
  • What assumptions do I take into important conversations?
  • How does the way I ask questions affect what others dare to say?
  • To what extent do I invite dialogue, not just answers?
  • How does the language of our team shape what we see as possible?

Gadamer reminds us of something simple but demanding. We do not understand the world as it is, we understand it through who we are, in the face of others. For leaders, it means that the most important task is not just to create results, but to create spaces for common understanding. In that space both psychological security, learning and real development arise. That's where change begins.

References

Gadamer, H.-G. (2004). Truth and method (2nd rev. ed.). Continuum.

Edmondson, A.C. (2019). Fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. Wiley.

Schein, E. H., & Schein, P. (2018). Humble leadership: The power of relationships, openness, and trust. Berrett-Koehler.

Argyris, C. (1991). Teach smart people how to learn. Harvard Business Review, 69 (3), 99—109.

Contact Us
Jon-Rune Nygård
Leadership coach and advisor